Subscribe to our FREE Newsletter 'Great Things to do in Melbourne - the White Hat guide'


A Monument to Sydney-Melbourne Rivalry

This article was first published in the  White Hat Melbourne Newsletter No.204 on 1 February 2007

Monument�You think someone would remove it or tidy it up.� The visitors were obviously from that area of Europe where tidiness is written into the constitution. And I had to admit that the large lump of stone on a rudely constructed base was less than impressive.

Our visitors were not to know that it was really a monument to Sydney-Melbourne rivalry. Maybe a little background to the origins of this strange preoccupation well known to most Australians. Melbourne was a late starter. By the time the rival parties of Batman and Fawkner arrived in the area in 1835 to form the little European settlement, Sydney had been established for nearly fifty years. The authorities arrived from Sydney to inspect. There had been several attempts at government-sanctioned settlements in the Port Phillip area but none were sustainable. However the authorities from Sydney had to reluctantly admit that, unlike their own attempts, this settlement initiated by private enterprise seemed viable. Score one to Melbourne.

However it would have to have laws and taxes and be governed from Sydney. Score ten to Sydney.

Governor Bourke from Sydney arrived and had his military surveyor Robert Hoddle lay out a street grid for Melbourne. Governor Bourke then named the streets making sure that he got top billing. Thus Bourke Street in Melbourne is named after the governor from Sydney.

For fifteen years all major decisions about Melbourne were made in Sydney by people who for the most had never seen the place and often expressed distaste at the prospect of one day doing so. One of the first public buildings they decided Melbourne should have was a gaol. A large gaol. Up on the hill where it would dominate the skyline of the town. �Can you imagine!� said the people of Melbourne. �Just because their town is a penal settlement crawling with convicts they think our town, founded by an Australian-born free settler, needs a large gaol. We all came to this part of the world of our own accord and if some don�t want to talk much about their background that�s their prerogative.� The foundations of the Melbourne-Sydney resentment were becoming well and truly established.

During this period, two major social issues that attracted heated comment were �anti-transportation� and �separation�. Anti-transportation referred to opposing the use of the Port Phillip area as a penal settlement where convicts from England could be transported. That would keep the settlement on a higher moral plane than those up north. The issue of separation referred to separation from New South Wales and becoming an independent colony. In another settlement one would expect a label such as �colonial status� to be used for such an aspiration. But in Melbourne the key word was separation � separation from Sydney!

In 1851, word arrived from Queen Victoria that Melbourne was to become part of a separate colony (named after herself of course) and there were unprecedented celebrations. Bonfires were lit across the state, one week�s public holiday was declared and a grand separation procession was held through the streets of Melbourne. Scarcely had the last bonfire embers ceased to glow when it was announced that gold had been discovered in country Victoria. With gold money pouring in, Melbourne set about building itself a Parliament House. But no ordinary Parliament House. This was to be much bigger and much more impressive than Sydney�s. We were very proud of our Parliament House but there was one minor point which people knew you did not mention in polite society. It remained unmentioned until an engineer (who on the whole are not renowned for their mastery of social niceties) erected this monument.

The inscription reads: �This pillar of stone quarried from Stawell was placed here on the INSISTENCE of the Hon. John Woods, M.P. (born Liverpool England November 5th 1822, died Brighton Victoria April 2nd 1892; engineer, politician and inventor, Commissioner International Exhibition 1880 and Exhibition Trustees 1881�1892) to express his INDIGNATION of the choice of New South Wales stone for Parliament House and to show the enduring qualities of local stone.�

I think of suggesting to our visitors that if they read the inscription they might understand why that lump of stone is there. On second thoughts I suspect that would only make them more confused.


Copyright © 1995 - 2024 White Hat.

Other articles in the series Seven Monuments of Melbourne:

Seven Monuments of Melbourne - overview

No.1 � A Monument to Sydney-Melbourne Rivalry
No.2 � Two Yarra Bookends
No.3 - An Antarctic Monument
No.4 � Troubles on the other side of the world
No.5 - A Plaque but no Statue
No.6 - Two Pillars of Melbourne
No.7 - Two Horse Troughs

You can find a comprehensive guide to markets around Australia at The White Hat Guide to Markets in Australia.